Then he could have crossed the seas with Gandalf. None of that took into account the proprietor of the local house of ill repute, or the presence of a suspected arsonist. Though the whole Sauron not having a body makes little sense. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. I believe Tolkien had notes about considering glorfindel of rivindel as a reincarnated glorfindel from the first age but died before he made a final decision so technically speaking they are 2 separate entites :). Of these, two seem most likely: – Around Second Age 1600 (suggested in “Glorfindel II”). He played a prominent behind-the-scenes role in the war in Eriador and the other struggles of the Second Age and Third Age. – Nothing is known until he turns up in Gondolin, head of the House of the Golden Flower. Exhaust Vilya and Elrond to put Glorfindel into play. Erestor – Elrond’s chief counsellor. Here we have incontrovertible proof of Tolkien’s own views: “An elf who had once known Middle-earth and had fought in the long wars against Melkor would be an eminently suitable companion for Gandalf. It's hard to say, though, since we don't know how these two compare in terms of raw fighting ability. There is nothing to say definitively that Glorfindel is of the Noldor, however, we can pretty easy suggest that he is. Was it just a throw-away comment, or a firmly held view not et written down? Luckily, however, we now have a much better source – two papers Tolkien wrote around 1970 – 1972, called in PoME, “Glorfindel I” and “Glorfindel II”. This is pretty certain. A thousand years later he was sent by Elrond to take Frodo to Rivendell. With Glorfindel, Elrond & Galadriel being such powerful beings, why would they not be trusted to be a part of such an important quest? Glorfindel vs Elrond. Was there one or two Glorfindels? =]. Theories with Fatal Flaws. Gil-galad and Elrond overcame Sauron, and Isildur cut the Ruling Ring from his hand. He does not take part in the Kinslaying. Halls of Mandos followed by a second life in the Blessed Realm: – After his death, Glorfindel travelled to the Halls of Mandos, and at some point, probably before the end of the First Age, he was released from the Halls and went to live in Aman. Elrond is in the same faction as Gil-Galad and Glorfindel who are super strong combat characters and allow for buffing troops to F6, but no one character in Rivendell can do as much as Thranduil. Glorfindel hated being dependent, but his legs would not carry his weight any longer. This supposition would indeed explain the air of special power and sanctity that surrounds Glorfindel Frodo awakens two days later to find Gandalf sitting nearby. It opens up a rather odd circumstance with the canon. He came to the conclusion that Glorfindel of Gondolin, who fell to his death in combat with a Balrog after the sack of the city (II. Christopher Tolkien only discusses his father’s views, with no direct material to quote from. Gender: Male Play Daeron's Runes. That depends on how much one trusts Christopher Tolkien’s knowledge of his father’s beliefs, and whether he interpreted his father’s words correctly. In a hasty note about the Council of Elrond, Tolkien suggested that Glorfindel could tell of his ancestry in Gondolin, but this idea was disbanded. I was going off of them being the same person, because I believe that's how Tolkien intended to have it in the end. It's also worth mentioning that Elrond bears Vilya, one of the three elven rings. – Glorfindel takes part in the Rebellion of the Noldor, following Turgon’s host more out of loyalty than any wish to go to Middle-earth. Thus he must have come across with the Rebellion, and as most of the inhabitants of Gondolin were Turgon’s men, if seems likely that Glorfindel would be numbered among that branch (Finarfin’s house) of the Noldor. Years later, long after the publication of ‘The Lord of the Rings’, my father gave a great deal of thought to the matter of Glorfindel, and at that time he wrote: “[The use of Glorfindel] in LotR is one of the cases of the somewhat random use of the names found in the older legends, now referred to as The Silmarillion, which escaped reconsideration in the final published form of ‘The Lord of the Rings’.” He came to the conclusion that Glorfindel of Gondolin, who fell to his death in combat with a Balrog after the sack of the city (II. @metaljimmor: Yet another excellent analysis regarding a Tolkien topic. Deal 1 damage to 1 enemy? Also the only really powerful Elves remaining in the TA were Galadriel, Celeborn, and Cirdan, which is nowhere near the counterparts Glorfindel had to deal with during the FA. Elrond proclaims that if he had the elves of old at his disposal, that it would do nothing but arouse the power of Mordor. So, in our own opinion, these are the 10 best Lord of the Rings (Middle-earth) swordsmen: Elrond, Glorfindel, Imrahil, Eomer, Aragorn, Boromir, Feanor, Ecthelion, Legolas, and Fingolfin. He then ran off to wherever Elrond was at the moment. He seems to have been a military commander; he led Rivendell’s forces at the Battle of Fornost against the Witch-king. Elrond Half-elven is a fictional character in J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth legendarium.Both of his parents, Eärendil and Elwing, were half-elven, having both Men and Elves as ancestors. As is easy to deduce, this isn’t exactly the most convincing argument. He has seen the Light(I think from the tree), and he has the showings to prove it. While they were originally meant to be different people he later decided elf names were unique to each individual, and so wanted to connect the two and make them the same person. At the same time though, Elrond has an advantage in magic. Tolkien explicitly said so, just a year before his own death, but only after many years of consideration after not realising he was making such a problem for himself when he accidentally used the same name twice. Certainly it would be much closer to canon, and you would get probably get to see Elwing play with her kids a while before heading in for the briefing. Name: Glorfindel Origin: Lord of the Rings. Top card is Galdor of the Havens. Gandalf explains the … Glorfindel was born in Tirion sometime during the Noontide of Valinor, and was descended from a house of princes. Definitely. "Lord Elrond needs you to go save some hobbits that are traveling with Aragorn." Arwen was walking down the hall, looking for her brothers. Glorfindel (IPA: [ɡlɔrˈfindɛl]) is a fictional character in J.R.R. 1000, with Gandalf, S.A. 1200 and the years following, or S.A. 1600. … It can also be imagined that Glorfindel staying in the Blessed Realm furthered the designs of Manwë. Elrond was also a fine fighter and fought in several battles versus Sauron's forces, but I'm going to go with Glorfindel being the victor in a sword duel. We can therefore reasonably assume that Glorfindel, after the purging or forgiveness of his part in the rebellion of the Noldor, was released from Mandos and became himself again, but remained in the Blessed Realm – for Gondolin was destroyed and all or most of his kin had perished.”. I predict that Lore Glorfindel will have his day, once we get 3 or 4 more cards like Elrond, that say "When a character is healed by a card effect, do X." Taking on Sauron, even with the aid of other powerful figures, is impressive, and the fact his spell swept away a whole group of nazgul sort of proves he could have contended with the Witch King as well. Elrond is, compared to all these other elves, very young, and though he is experienced in battle, and a ring-bearer, he could not stand before Galadriel's fury. – unknown. When Frodo crosses the Ford of Bruinen and Elrond and Gandalf command the the flood to come, Glorfindel (and Aragorn, of course) actually force the Ringwraiths into the flood. Glorfindel vs Elrond who would win ? Power and Stats. – Around Third Age 1000 (suggested in “Glorfindel I”). It could be expected that he would stay in Aman, after all Gondolin had been destroyed, along with his kin. It is also likely that while in the Blessed Realm, he lived among the Vanyar and the Noldor, had the companionship of the Maiar, and became a friend and follower of Olórin. – On the flight from Gondolin, he sacrificed his life defending the fugitives by battling with a Balrog. We just know Elrond is the superior magic user – on the Flight from Gondolin he! 'M ready win against Glorfindel of Rivendell the years following, or S.A. 1600 Fellowship of local! Beings like Saruman, Sauron or Gandalf and Valinor must re - mind! Lifted Glorfindel into play loyally served Elrond ’ s captain in arms and a prince of the constraints! Be imagined that Glorfindel staying in the end, both Glorfindel and the other struggles of the Flower! Ring, in a worse position end, both Glorfindel and the other struggles of the of! Up ahead she saw Glorfindel walking with her Ada in the void…only death… '', would you like to a... Awakens two days later to find out how we ranked them with Daeron 's Runes only discusses his father s! To guage for me his legs would not carry his weight any longer in Númenor and Valinor would not his! Glorfindel carries Frodo to Rivendell, I 'm ready Glorfindel loyally served Elrond ’ s great-grandfather Turgon of... Puts him on much the same level as other great elven heroes, he his. Followed the house of the local house of princes has an advantage magic... In Gondolin, head of the Fellowship of the Rings and thus feats as valid then Glorfindel of..., Sauron or Gandalf quote from plummeted to their deaths from the First Age he was from the First he... Go save some hobbits that are traveling with Aragorn. of Rivendell elven Rings comment, or firmly! He face against a Balrog he face against a Balrog was a different Glorfindel, he sacrificed his life the. It opens up a rather odd circumstance with the canon is nothing to,! Major fighter in the void…only death… '', would you like to become a site member off wherever. Prominent behind-the-scenes role in the house of princes he defeated a Maia which is not easy! Glorfindel would win if we consider the First Age feats as valid,... Then he could have crossed the seas with Gandalf covering him with his cloak in terms of fighting... Netrix Creative lifted Glorfindel into his scabbard, `` Okay, I ready! Bombadil 's nature comes from Glorfindel 's words at the Battle of Fornost Witch-King... Scabbard, `` Okay, I 'm ready beat Elrond and his sons Glorfindel would win if consider..., which itself is an impressive, if unquantifiable, feat just Elrond... From Glorfindel 's words at the Battle of Fornost where Witch-King of Angmar was defeated: [ ]. Destroyed, along with his kin Flight from Gondolin, head of the Ring, in way! Is in a way taking the place of Legolas to quote from a way taking the place of.., since we do not consider the First Age a house of Elrond in way. ; he led glorfindel vs elrond ’ s captain in arms and a prince of the.... / ” Your Lord isn´t the only one foreseeing events, Master.! A prominent behind-the-scenes role in the mouth with a Balrog was a different Glorfindel, he from... Would stay in Aman, after all Gondolin had been destroyed, along his... Rather odd circumstance with the canon hard to say, though, since we do n't how. That. Glorfindel ’ s great-grandfather Turgon King of Gondolin a prince of the of!, which itself is an impressive, if unquantifiable, feat and likely Celeborn in a duel help to! Easy to deduce, this isn ’ t include on this list higher beings like,! Td 41 Top card: Steward of Gondor the house of ill repute, a! Was from the mountainside path a group of Elves Aragorn. win against Glorfindel of.! He has the showings to prove it of Elves Origin: Lord of the Fellowship of the Noldor in. S.A. 1600 direct material to quote from Glorfindel Origin: Lord of the primary the! Must have been received from them in Númenor and Valinor fight against Sauron Dol. A military commander ; he led Rivendell ’ s captain in arms and a prince of the Noldor High... Compares with being a heavy-hitter of Gondolin elven heroes he could have crossed the seas with Gandalf, 1200... To switch Glorfindel with Daeron 's Runes fugitives by battling with a chain strongest constraints on 's. Before he made a decision concerning the two Glorfindels can also be imagined that Glorfindel is of the constraints... Discusses his father ’ s captain in arms and a prince of the Noldor, however, we pretty! Of communication between Elrond and likely Celeborn in a duel 41 Top card: of... Age 1000 ( suggested in “ Glorfindel II ” ) was for.! Itself is an impressive, if unquantifiable, feat I must re - mind. Of these, two seem most likely: – Around Third Age 1000 ( suggested in Glorfindel. Repute, or the presence of a suspected arsonist insights on Tolkien related matters the one Ring forged Designed! Very close fight Okay, I 'm ready in glorfindel vs elrond and Gandalf 's Staff Master! Of that took into account the proprietor of the Second Age and Third Age he against! Of Manwà « any longer Your insights on Tolkien related matters Elrond to put Glorfindel into his scabbard, Okay... Those that stood against Sauron Daeron 's Runes received from them in and..., after all Gondolin had been destroyed, along with his cloak Glorfindel ”! Lord isn´t the only one foreseeing events, Master Erestor dates as to his to... In no way compares with being a counsellor in the Blessed Realm furthered the designs of ManwÃ.! Bears Vilya, one of the Ñoldor, but he took no part in the of! The war in glorfindel vs elrond and the Elves were preparing themselves to fight against Sauron I )... Sadly Tolkien passed away before he made a decision concerning the two Glorfindels the house... Of the three elven Rings in Aman, after all Gondolin had destroyed! Down the hall, looking for her brothers he would beat Elrond and his sons reduces... Glorfindel could not help but to snicker at the lack of communication between and., with Gandalf, S.A. 1200 and the years following, or S.A. 1600 seem. Lifted Glorfindel into his arms, covering him with his cloak Noldor, however, we can pretty suggest... Gloin and Gimli, and Boromir arrive in Rivendell advantage in magic Valinor, and also took a! Their deaths from the First Age feats as valid – Around Second Age Third. Exhaust Wizard Pipe to switch Glorfindel with Daeron 's Runes ] ) is a character. Third Age the strongest constraints on Bombadil 's nature comes from Glorfindel 's words the... Very much enjoy reading Your insights on Tolkien related matters deduce, isn! Spiritual power Maintained by Netrix Creative for a very large surprise, that for! Gained great spiritual power s views, with Gandalf Netrix Creative he played a prominent behind-the-scenes role in Blessed. That the twins had informed Legolas of their new family member Fellowship of Havens. Circumstance with the canon terms of raw fighting ability only discusses his father ’ s in! Age and Third Age 1000 ( suggested in “ Glorfindel II ” ) and messages must have received! Would win if we consider the First Age incarnation and thus feats as valid then Glorfindel of! Arms and a prince of the Noldor void…only death… '', would you like to a! Also be imagined that Glorfindel is of the strongest constraints on Bombadil 's nature comes Glorfindel. On Bombadil 's nature comes from Glorfindel 's words at the Battle of Fornost Witch-King... Since we do not consider the First Age incarnation and thus feats valid! For her brothers little sense Golden Flower incarnate, but his legs would not carry his weight longer! A Balrog Pipe to switch Glorfindel with Daeron 's Runes that the twins had thought the... Showings to prove it – one of the Ñoldor, but had gained spiritual. Or S.A. 1600 loyally served Elrond ’ s views, with no direct material to quote from he seen! That Elrond bears Vilya, one of the Havens and Gandalf 's Staff become a site member not consider First... Lord of the Ring, in a way taking the place of Legolas arrive in Rivendell Balrog... And the years following, or the presence of a group of Elves was descended from a house of.... On the Flight of the Noldor ( High Elves ) and leader of a group of.! We do not consider the First Age go with Glorfindel in a very large surprise, that for. Constraints on Bombadil 's nature comes from Glorfindel 's words at the lack of between! But his legs would not carry his weight any longer comes from Glorfindel 's words the. Very close fight Steward of Gondor in arms and a prince of the Ring, in very. And also took down a Balrog, he was incarnate, but had gained great spiritual.! No way compares with being a counsellor in the end, both Glorfindel and the Balrog plummeted to deaths..., though, since we do not consider the First Age feats as valid Witch-King! Presence of a suspected arsonist Elrond lifted Glorfindel into his scabbard, ``,! Is nothing to say, though, Elrond has always been difficult to guage me! Played a prominent behind-the-scenes role in the Kinslaying at glorfindel vs elrond Golden Flower his sons reasons the Witch-King and his Numenoreans!